FOR THE NEXT GENERATION OF PHYSICIANS
← All news & updates
THE GUARDIAN · HEALTH · November 19, 2026

Lawyer calls for urgent review of Letby convictions after expert witness revelations

THE SHORT VERSION

Lucy Letby's legal team is seeking a review of her convictions, citing the failure to disclose that a key expert witness was barred from clinical practice due to safety concerns. The expert, Prof Peter Hindmarsh, provided crucial testimony about insulin poisoning in the case. The jury was not informed of Hindmarsh's exclusion from clinical practice, which occurred in March 2023.

Letby's lawyer argues that this undisclosed information raises significant questions about the safety of her convictions. He has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission for a re-examination of the case. The prosecution described Hindmarsh as the leading expert on insulin, but his exclusion from clinical practice was not disclosed to the defense or the jury.

Legal experts suggest that the non-disclosure of such critical information could be grounds for an appeal. The Criminal Procedure Rules mandate that expert witnesses must disclose any disciplinary proceedings that could undermine their credibility. Letby's defense team was not informed about Hindmarsh's exclusion from practice or the tribunal ruling in April 2023.

Read the full story on The Guardian · Health

This summary was written with AI assistance from the original article and may leave out important context. The original reporting belongs to The Guardian · Health. Check the original, and official sources, before acting on any detail.