FOR THE NEXT GENERATION OF PHYSICIANS
← All USMLE guides
PSYCHIATRY AND BEHAVIORAL SCIENCE

Medical ethics: informed consent, capacity and confidentiality.

Elements of consent, decision-making capacity, surrogate decision makers, minors, when confidentiality may be broken and advance directives.

Ethics questions have one principle at the center: respect the patient autonomy unless a clear exception applies.

Consent and capacity

Informed consent requires disclosure of risks, benefits and alternatives, a voluntary choice and capacity. Capacity means understanding, appreciating, reasoning and expressing a choice, and it is decision specific. Competence is a legal term. Treat without consent in an emergency with implied consent.

Surrogates and directives

If the patient lacks capacity and has no advance directive, use the legally designated surrogate (spouse, adult children, parents, siblings). A living will and durable power of attorney guide decisions. Do-not-resuscitate orders are honored in the setting stated.

Confidentiality and minors

Breaches are allowed for reportable diseases, abuse and imminent danger to an identifiable person (Tarasoff). Adolescents can consent for contraception, STI care, pregnancy and substance treatment in most states. Parents can refuse treatment for children, but courts intervene in life-threatening cases.

Keep going in psychiatry and behavioral science

Related on USMLE WEB

Frequently asked questions

Can a patient refuse life-saving treatment?

Yes, if they have capacity.

When can confidentiality be broken?

Imminent danger to others, abuse reporting and reportable diseases.